This extraordinary novel, full of twists and turns, giving glimpses of lives under Bolshevik rule, the speedy disillusionment and the increasing betrayals, wastes not a single word as it swoops from universal images of winter city streets to relationships and domestic scenes. - Glasgow Herald
The paradox of freedom and necessity is thoroughly explored through dialogues and descriptions. Serge and his excellent translator Richard Greeman sympathise with the paradox rather than seeing the outcome as inevitable when the idea of Man is pitted against the actuality of people. If such views seem antiquated or foreign, then all the more reason to read Victor Serge with a degree of sympathy. - Times Literary Supplement
A remarkable novel, cool, sophisticated, intelligent and reasoned… Read this novel: it teaches so much about history, how it is made and unmade; how humans look to it for answers only to reject them. - Irish Times